COMMENTARY

Scandal and Conscience: Joining VOTF as an Act of Conscience
Sally Vance-Trembath, VOTF National vice president

Gaile Pohlhaus and I have been asked to serve VOTF by offering theological reflection on a regular basis in the Vineyard. The theme for VOTF's Spring Action this year is the notion of conscience in Catholic theology. Given that, and the recent excommunications" in Nebraska, we thought it worth devoting some time to the adjacent notion of scandal.

A well-formed conscience will use the "avoidance of scandal" as one of its tests in making a good decision. Scandal is one of those multi-valent words. Like the word reception, it has a common discourse meaning as well as a technical theological meaning. In both its common use and its theological use, the word scandal derives from the Greek word for "snare" or that which causes us to trip or stumble. Theologically it refers to those actions or failures that might damage someone else's relationship with God. In other words, we can "cause scandal" by our actions and that adds another layer of gravity to a sin.

When I was invited to speak to a newly formed VOTF group here in San Francisco by Peg and Ed Gleason, I quickly discerned that failing to speak might damage the faith of my students and especially of my own children. What kind of theologian would I be if I failed to confront this situation? In the years since then, I have always set aside one day in my Catholicism courses to explicitly discuss this crisis. Not to do so would be a scandal. How?

Let us suppose that one of my Catholic students was talking with one of her peers who is attending Santa Clara, not because it is Catholic but because it is a rigorous, intellectual environment. And let us further suppose that my student is asked to say what she thinks about pedophile priests. In her theology class, my students should be given the tools to help her questioner understand the situation using the same intellectual rigor that she is asked to use in her chemistry or rhetoric class. If I had not given my student those tools, her confidence in the Church might appear foolish to her friend. After just a couple conversations like that, my student's own relationship with God might be dented. Certainly her relationship with the Church would be. My failure to provide her with those tools would be a significant factor because I am responsible to both my student and to the Church.

So relationships are at the heart of the teaching on scandal. Just as there are people in my parish whose relationship with God gives me life and nourishes my own faith life, the opposite can happen as well. There are actions that can damage the inner life of others. I think this is what Fr. Tom Doyle means when he talks about abuse as "soul murder".

Like so many teachings in Catholic theology, these two aspects of scandal are two sides of the same theological coin. Sin is ultimately damage to our relationship with God; the absence of sin is one description of a relationship with God in which we are able to rest and draw strength and comfort. In this way, a scandal is a kind of assault on our relationship with God. Because the Church is such an intense location for our relationship with God, our relationship with the Church often gets identified with our relationship with God. This has been one of the enduring dangers of the Catholic way of thinking, that is, the easy slippage towards thinking that the Church is God's Reign on earth. It is not. However, the Church does serve God's Reign and the Catholic Church teaches that it is the richest servant of that Reign available to the human community. Institutional forms are quite secondary to the mystery of God's presence in the whole people of God gathered in the power of the Holy Spirit for the sake of Jesus' historic mission. However, Catholicism claims that these institutional forms are very important and effective. Because we are incarnate, creatures of the real, concrete, natural world, there are fundamentally humane ways to deepen and nourish our work for the Reign of God.

The particular institutional forms where we exercise Christian ministry are very powerful in the formation of other people's faith life. They all have the same root: Baptism. In Baptism we accept the Christian truth claim that all our relationships of love are everlasting, that the Creator of the Cosmos loves every person, that God's own personal presence as Spirit is a feature of the inner life of every person. These are the core truth claims of Christianity. They must be at the center of every action we take. When they are not, their absence might be the "snare" that keeps a questioning young person away from the Church.

The same woman who asked me to join VOTF five years ago, Peg Gleason, has given us one of the best descriptions of scandal that I have ever heard. She tells of raising six children in the Viet Nam years and of marching against Viet Nam. When she explained to her then-young children why she marched, she said it was so they "would never have to kill another mother's child in a war." Years later, when she was discussing the abuse of children by priests with her adult children, they said that when they were younger, they had friends who were molested. When she asked them why they did not come to her they said that they thought that the priests were so important to her that she might not believe what her children had to say.

Peg says she recognized the depths of the scandal at that moment. Why scandal? The deep respect that Peg had developed for pastors had been turned into an obstacle in her relationship with her children and had blocked her ability to minister to them in the name of the Church. The trustworthy mother with whom they could discuss war and peace had been made unavailable to them because peace had been made unavailable to them. They did not trust the institutional Church. Their mother was less credible precisely because she still placed her trust in the Church. They could trust her to question the government, but could not trust her to question the Church. Because of this, their own human and legitimate questions about the Church were called into question. Having been formed to appropriately raise questions, especially questions regarding justice and the dignity of human persons, they could not give allegiance to a Church that seemed not to allow such questioning. And there is the heart of the scandal. The Church appeared to value the institutional form at the expense of young people. In so doing, the Church severed the connection with the Reign of God; in the Reign of God, each person's value and dignity is protected and lifted-up. Five years later, Peg is still working for VOTF to protect children, support priests who work for Jesus' mission and to change the systems that protected abusers. Why does she continue? To stop would be a scandal.

[See the VOTF Lenten Action on Conscience on the VOTF website.]

 



In the Vineyard
February 8, 2007
Volume 6, Issue 3 Printer Friendly Version (PDF)


Page One

National News Update

Diocese/State Watch

VOTF Lenten Action on Conscience 2007

Commentary:
Theologian’s Corner:
“Scandal and Conscience” – Sally Vance-Trembath, VOTF vice president

“Something Special Happened Here” – Vince Grenough, VOTF Louisville KY

Report from New York” – Francis Piderit, VOTF NY on the “state of the diocese” with regard to parish closings

“’Getting it’ in the Bridgeport CT diocese” – Dan Sullivan, VOTF Bridgeport


Structural Change Working Group

Voice of Renewal/Lay Education

Prayerful Voice

Goal 2 - Priest Support


Donate

Join VOTF

Contact Us 

Archives


VOTF Home

For an overview of press coverage of VOTF, click here.

VOTF relies solely on the contributions of people like you to support its work.
©Voice of the Faithful 2007.All Rights Reserved