LETTER TO THE EDITOR

This letter is a response to the August 11 commentary from Maria Rodrigues on the closing of her son’s elementary school. What follows is one mother’s response on behalf of another. The writer is addressing Maria but appeals to all mothers:

“I know that Voice of the Faithful has done many responsible and kind things in support of victims of clergy abuse, and I also understand your deep feelings of hurt at experiencing the pain surrounding your young son at the prospect of losing his school. I can identify with the need to try and make things right for him. This piece, though, arouses in me such a need to try and meet you on the level of mother, a mother who loves her son. Help me to understand why all Catholic mothers have not railed at this same church and what it has done to thousands of our sons, and daughters.

I am going to speak on behalf of a mother who is no longer with us and therefore cannot speak for herself. Were she here I feel certain she would say the following:

What about my son? Why do you good Catholics not care about him? Why are you not joined in solidarity screaming out at the horrible treatment he met each day at his school? Talk to him now. Let him tell you what it was like to arise each morning and try and decide what to wear to school because he knew the clothes he chose were going to be ripped from his body and possibly torn as he was subjected to the daily rape of his body by his priest. He was sodomized nearly every single day for two years until he could endure it no longer. He finally had to quit school. He never returned, and to this day has never gotten an education.

He is a grown man now, but each day he remembers. He remembers the cost to me as I lost my faith, my sense of hope and belief in the church in which I was raised and was raising my family. He remembers his own fear, his shame, the pain of the sodomy, and the lack of understanding at why no one was helping him. He was raped in classrooms, in the principal’s office, at other Catholic schools. He remembers the anger, wanting to kill the priest. He remembers how I simply gave up when I couldn't help or get anything done about this injustice. He still believes to this day that his abuse is what killed me and he is right.

Where is the movement to action by mothers for this injustice? Who among you will stand up for my son? He is still angry, still hurts, and still cannot get anything done. His rapist priest was finally taken away to a mental hospital where he died, having been moved many times after many unsuccessful attempts to get him to stop what he was doing. His victims are so many, and number among them his own brother priests, and yet no one takes a stand for my son. Why do Catholic mothers not fight for our sons? I tried, but I was alone, and, as always, the powerful church won. Though I understand your wanting your son to get a good education in a particular school, I warn you to guard him well. If you believe the problem of abuse is solved, you are mistaken. Keep him close to you. I hope you never experience the pain brought into my life by this evil, uncaring church. I could not live with my pain at not being able to help my son. I wish you success with yours.”

Sincerely, a mother just like you



In the Vineyard
August 25, 2005
Volume 4, Issue 9
Printer Friendly Version

Page One

VOTF At Work in the World

Commentary [What do you think? Respond to pthorp.ed@votf.org] VOTF members, attorneys Bob Morris and Sharon Harrington, consider the ramifications of legislation that would require a church to open its books.


Donate

Join VOTF

Contact Us 

VOTF Home

For an overview of press coverage of VOTF, click here.
©Voice of the Faithful 2005.All Rights Reserved